Researched comparisonLast updated October 2026 · How we review
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products from established brands.
Quick Answer
The POLYWOOD Presidential is our pick for most porches: it has the lowest price here, a 300 lb capacity and a 20 year residential warranty. The highwood Lehigh holds the most at 400 lb and is the lightest chair at 34 lb. The Trex Yacht Club Rocker, made by POLYWOOD for Trex, has a slightly higher 17 inch seat and the same 20 year residential warranty as the POLYWOOD.
- POLYWOOD Presidential Rocking Chair: best for buyers who want a tall-backed porch rocker, 44.2 in, in HDPE lumber with a 300 lb capacity
- highwood Lehigh Rocking Chair: best for people who want the highest weight capacity here, 400 lb, in the lightest chair at 34 lb
- Trex Outdoor Furniture Yacht Club Rocking Chair: best for buyers who want a 17 in seat height and a 300 lb capacity in HDPE lumber
Prices as of October 17, 2026, 1:02 pm CT.
A rocking chair is a porch classic, and plastic lumber versions are made to stay outdoors. We compared three outdoor rocking chairs from POLYWOOD, highwood and Trex Outdoor Furniture, all built from heavy plastic lumber.
How We Chose
We picked three well-known outdoor furniture brands that make a classic porch rocker in plastic lumber. Trex Outdoor Furniture is made and sold by POLYWOOD under a trademark license from Trex, so two of these chairs come from the same manufacturer, though the designs and sizes differ. Prices vary by color, so we compare the black POLYWOOD and highwood chairs and the Stepping Stone Trex. highwood’s warranty is shorter for white pieces, which is one reason we compare black. Specs come from each manufacturer’s own product pages. Each card lists the warranty from the manufacturer’s own warranty page. Prices are the Amazon prices on the date shown.
The Lineup
Specs come from each manufacturer’s own pages. Prices as of October 17, 2026, 1:02 pm CT. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. Amazon may show a different seller than the brand or Amazon.com. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided “as is” and is subject to change or removal at any time.
POLYWOOD Presidential Rocking Chair
$199.00 as of Oct 17, 2026, 1:02 pm CT on Amazon · Lowest price, tallest back
Best for: buyers who want a tall-backed porch rocker, 44.2 in, in HDPE lumber with a 300 lb capacity
POLYWOOD’s page for the Presidential Rocking Chair, model R100, lists 26.1 x 33.8 x 44.2 inches overall with a 16.1 inch seat height, a 20 inch wide seat and a 24.2 inch arm height. It weighs 37 pounds, holds 300 pounds, and is made from POLYWOOD’s HDPE lumber with marine-grade stainless steel fasteners. It comes in 20 colors and needs assembly. We like it for the classic tall back and the 20 year residential warranty at the lowest price here.
Warranty: 20 years residential
Check Price on Amazon →highwood Lehigh Rocking Chair
$318.00 as of Oct 17, 2026, 1:02 pm CT on Amazon · Highest capacity, lightest
Best for: people who want the highest weight capacity here, 400 lb, in the lightest chair at 34 lb
highwood’s page for the Lehigh Rocking Chair lists 27.21 x 32.75 x 43.98 inches assembled with a 17.26 inch seat height and a 23.25 inch wide seat, the widest here. It weighs 34 pounds, holds 400 pounds load-tested to ASTM standards, and is made in the USA from recycled plastics with 304-grade stainless steel hardware. Some assembly is required. We like it for the wide seat and the extra weight capacity.
Warranty: 12 years residential
Check Price on Amazon →Trex Outdoor Furniture Yacht Club Rocking Chair
$259.00 as of Oct 17, 2026, 1:02 pm CT on Amazon · Made by POLYWOOD for Trex
Best for: buyers who want a 17 in seat height and a 300 lb capacity in HDPE lumber
Trex Outdoor Furniture’s page for the Yacht Club Rocking Chair, model TXR100, lists 26.3 x 33.8 x 42.5 inches overall with a 17 inch seat height and a 20 inch wide, 19 inch deep seat. It weighs 37 pounds, holds 300 pounds and is built from Genuine POLYWOOD lumber, which Trex describes as HDPE made in the USA. It comes in seven colors and needs assembly. We like it for the slightly higher seat and the same 20 year residential warranty as the POLYWOOD.
Warranty: 20 years residential
Check Price on Amazon →Our Take
Pick the POLYWOOD Presidential for a classic tall-backed porch rocker at the lowest price, with a 20 year residential warranty. Pick the highwood Lehigh if you want the widest seat and the highest weight capacity at 400 lb. Pick the Trex Yacht Club Rocker if you like its look and want a slightly higher seat with the same 20 year residential warranty as the POLYWOOD.
More Patio Guides: All Patio Guides · Best Gazebos 2026 · Best Propane Fire Pits 2026 · Best Electric Patio Heaters 2026 · Best Outdoor Rugs 2026 · Best 9 Ft Patio Umbrellas 2026 · Best Outdoor Bluetooth Speakers 2026 · Best Propane Patio Heaters 2026 · Best Deck Boxes for Your Patio 2026 · Best Adirondack Chairs 2026 · Best Outdoor String Lights 2026 · Best Smokeless Fire Pits 2026 · Best Outdoor Benches 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What are these rocking chairs made of?
POLYWOOD and Trex Outdoor Furniture use POLYWOOD’s HDPE lumber, and Trex says its furniture is made in the USA. highwood makes the Lehigh in the USA from recycled plastics with 304-grade stainless steel hardware.
Do they need assembly?
Yes. POLYWOOD says the Presidential requires assembly, highwood says some assembly is required, and Trex provides assembly instructions and a video for the Yacht Club Rocker.
How much weight can they hold?
highwood lists 400 pounds for the Lehigh. POLYWOOD and Trex each list 300 pounds.
Does the color affect the price or warranty?
Prices on Amazon change by color for all three chairs. highwood’s warranty certificate gives white pieces a 3 year warranty instead of 12 years, so check the color before you buy.
What warranty do they have?
POLYWOOD and Trex Outdoor Furniture each give 20 years of residential coverage on the lumber and 5 years on hardware. highwood gives 12 years of residential coverage, except white pieces at 3 years.
