Researched comparisonLast updated October 2026 · How we review
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products from established brands.
Quick Answer
Emsco is the lowest-priced pick, Garant is the 18 inch shovel with a hardwood handle, and Suncast has the widest blade at 24 inches with a galvanized steel wear strip.
- Suncast 24 Inch Combo Snow Shovel Pusher (SC2450KDD): best for a 24 inch shovel and pusher combination with a galvanized steel wear strip
- Garant Nordic 18 Inch Poly Blade Snow Shovel (NPM18KD): best for an 18 inch poly blade shovel with a 42 inch hardwood handle and a ribbed D-grip
- Emsco Bigfoot 18 Inch Combination Snow Shovel (1197-1): best for a low-cost 18 inch combination shovel with a high-density polyethylene blade
Prices as of October 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT.
A good snow shovel is the difference between a quick pass down the walkway and a sore back. These three manual shovels from Suncast, Garant and Emsco are all combination designs that can shovel or push snow.
How We Chose
We picked one manual snow shovel from each of Suncast, Garant and Emsco. They are not identical: the Suncast is a 24 inch shovel and pusher combination with a steel shaft, the Garant is an 18 inch poly blade with a wooden handle, and the Emsco is an 18 inch combination shovel, so compare blade width and handle against the snow you usually clear. This is a researched comparison, and prices were checked this month. Specs come from each manufacturer’s own page where it gives them. Warranty terms come from the manufacturer’s own website where it names the model or product line, then from the Amazon listing, and we say so where neither gave a length. Each card lists the warranty.
The Lineup
Specs come from each manufacturer’s own pages. * Value from the Amazon listing, because the manufacturer’s page does not state it. Prices as of October 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. Amazon may show a different seller than the brand or Amazon.com. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided “as is” and is subject to change or removal at any time.
Suncast 24 Inch Combo Snow Shovel Pusher (SC2450KDD)
$50.34 as of Oct 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT on Amazon · Widest blade
Best for: a 24 inch shovel and pusher combination with a galvanized steel wear strip
Suncast’s page for the SC2450KDD lists a blade 24 inches wide and 12 inches high that combines a shovel and a pusher, with an angled rib pattern to resist snow sticking, a galvanized steel wear strip and a steel shaft with a rust-resistant powder-coated finish. The grip is a standard D-grip and the overall length is 51.25 inches. The page does not state a weight or the blade material, so the weight cell comes from the Amazon listing.
Warranty: 90 days limited
Check Price on Amazon →Garant Nordic 18 Inch Poly Blade Snow Shovel (NPM18KD)
$33.98 as of Oct 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT on Amazon · Hardwood handle
Best for: an 18 inch poly blade shovel with a 42 inch hardwood handle and a ribbed D-grip
Garant’s page for the NPM18KD lists an 18 inch polyethylene blade, a 42 inch stained hardwood handle with a ribbed poly D-grip, a total length of 51 inches and a weight of 3.34 pounds. Garant calls it a Mountain Mover that combines the best features of a shovel and a scraper, and describes it as ideal for occasional use on an entrance and walkway. The page does not mention a wear strip.
Warranty: 3 years
Check Price on Amazon →Emsco Bigfoot 18 Inch Combination Snow Shovel (1197-1)
$29.33 as of Oct 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT on Amazon · Lowest price
Best for: a low-cost 18 inch combination shovel with a high-density polyethylene blade
Emsco’s page for the Bigfoot combination snow shovel, SKU 1197-1, lists a scooping head of durable high-density polyethylene, dimensions of 5.25 by 18.25 by 49.5 inches and a weight of 4.31 pounds, and describes it as great for sidewalks, driveways and backyards. The page does not state the handle material or the grip type. It has the lowest price of the three.
Warranty: 1 year limited
Check Price on Amazon →Our Take
For the lowest price, the Emsco is the straightforward choice. Pick the Garant if you prefer a wooden handle and a lighter 18 inch blade, and the Suncast if you want the widest blade for clearing a driveway or patio. As general guidance, a narrower blade is easier to lift when the snow is heavy and wet.
More Yard Guides: All Yard Guides · Best Cordless Chainsaws 2026 · Best Garden Pump Sprayers 2026 · Best Leaf Vacuum Mulchers 2026 · Best Cordless Snow Blowers 2026 · Best Cordless String Trimmers 2026 · Best Garden Hose Nozzles 2026 · Best Hand Pruners 2026 · Best Cordless Leaf Blowers 2026 · Best Garden Hoses 2026 · Best Cordless Lawn Mowers 2026 · Best Lawn Spreaders 2026 · Best Lawn Sweepers 2026 · Best Lawn Edgers 2026 · Best Hose Reel Carts 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What size snow shovel should I get?
As general guidance, a wider blade moves more snow per pass but is heavier to lift when the snow is deep or wet. These range from an 18 inch blade on the Garant and Emsco to a 24 inch blade on the Suncast.
What is the difference between a snow shovel and a snow pusher?
A shovel lifts and throws snow, while a pusher moves it along the ground. All three here are combination designs: Suncast says its blade combines the elements of a shovel and a pusher, Garant describes a shovel and scraper, and Emsco calls its blade a combination shovel.
Which of these shovels has a wear strip?
Suncast lists a galvanized steel wear strip. Garant’s page does not mention one, and Emsco’s page does not either.
Which shovel is lightest?
Garant lists 3.34 pounds and Emsco lists 4.31 pounds. Suncast’s page does not list a weight, and the Amazon listing figure for it is 5.11 pounds.
What warranties do these shovels have?
Suncast lists a 90 day limited warranty, Garant lists 3 years on its product page, and Emsco lists a 1 year limited warranty. Each card links the manufacturer’s page where we found the term.
