Researched comparisonLast updated October 2026 · How we review
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products from established brands.
Quick Answer
Hiland is the lowest-priced pick and the smallest at 30 inches, Fire Sense has a lid that turns the 44 inch pit into a table, and Solo Stove has the highest heat output at up to 72,000 BTU and the longest warranty at 3 years.
- Fire Sense Florence Woven Aluminum Convertible Gas Fire Pit Table (62373): best for a 44 inch round aluminum fire pit with a lid that turns it into a patio table
- Hiland GSF-PR-PC 30 Inch Square Propane Fire Pit, Hammered Bronze: best for a compact 30 inch square propane fire pit at the lowest price of the three
- Solo Stove Infinity Flame 42 Inch Propane Fire Pit (FPSURROUND-GAS): best for a 42 inch round smokeless-style propane fire pit with the highest heat output of the three
Prices as of October 17, 2026, 10:08 am CT.
A propane fire pit gives you a flame without the wood, smoke or ash. These three come from Fire Sense, Hiland and Solo Stove, and they run on a standard 20 pound propane tank.
How We Chose
We picked one propane fire pit from each of Fire Sense, Hiland and Solo Stove. They are not the same size: the Hiland is a 30 inch square pit, while the Fire Sense and Solo Stove are 44 and 42 inches round, which is also why the Hiland costs a fraction as much, so match the size to your seating. This is a researched comparison, and prices were checked this month. Specs come from each manufacturer’s own page where it gives them, and values marked with an asterisk come from the Amazon listing. Warranty terms come from the manufacturer’s own website where it names the model, and we say so where it does not. Each card lists the warranty.
The Lineup
Specs come from each manufacturer’s own pages. * Value from the Amazon listing, because the manufacturer’s page does not state it. Prices as of October 17, 2026, 10:08 am CT. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. Amazon may show a different seller than the brand or Amazon.com. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided “as is” and is subject to change or removal at any time.
Fire Sense Florence Woven Aluminum Convertible Gas Fire Pit Table (62373)
$809.99 as of Oct 17, 2026, 10:08 am CT on Amazon · Lid converts it to a table
Best for: a 44 inch round aluminum fire pit with a lid that turns it into a patio table
The Florence page lists a 44 inch round woven aluminum fire pit that is 25.2 inches tall and weighs 85 pounds assembled, with a 55,000 BTU burner, clear fire glass, a fire bowl lid that converts it to a patio table, a fabric cover and a hinged door for a 20 pound propane tank. The page does not state the ignition type, hose and regulator, safety certification or runtime.
Warranty: 1 year limited
Check Price on Amazon →Hiland GSF-PR-PC 30 Inch Square Propane Fire Pit, Hammered Bronze
$149.00 as of Oct 17, 2026, 10:08 am CT on Amazon · Lowest price
Best for: a compact 30 inch square propane fire pit at the lowest price of the three
Hiland’s own website lists the GSF-PR-PC as a 30 inch square hammered bronze propane fire pit with 41,000 BTU. The site is a single page without a product spec sheet, so the height, weight and fire glass in the table come from the Amazon listing, which also lists a stainless steel lid, a regulator and hose, and a 20 pound propane tank. The manufacturer’s figure is the one in the table.
Warranty: 1 year limited, from the Amazon listing; Hiland’s site does not state one
Check Price on Amazon →Solo Stove Infinity Flame 42 Inch Propane Fire Pit (FPSURROUND-GAS)
$599.99 as of Oct 17, 2026, 10:08 am CT on Amazon · Most heat and longest warranty
Best for: a 42 inch round smokeless-style propane fire pit with the highest heat output of the three
Solo Stove’s page lists a 42 inch diameter, 20 inch tall propane fire pit that weighs 75.8 pounds with up to 72,000 BTU, instant ignition by a dial or push-button knob and a hidden compartment for a standard 20 pound propane tank. Runtime is about 5.5 hours on the highest setting. The page sells Black Pearl tempered fire glass in an 8 pound bag, and we could not confirm from the page that the glass ships with this exact SKU. The page does not list a lid.
Warranty: 3 years limited
Check Price on Amazon →Our Take
Pick the Hiland for a small patio and the lowest price. Pick the Fire Sense if you want the lid to turn the pit into a table when it is not lit. Pick the Solo Stove for the highest heat output and the 3 year warranty. As general guidance, keep a propane fire pit on a non-combustible surface and follow the manufacturer’s clearance instructions.
More Patio Guides: All Patio Guides · Best Electric Patio Heaters 2026 · Best Outdoor Rugs 2026 · Best 9 Ft Patio Umbrellas 2026 · Best Outdoor Bluetooth Speakers 2026 · Best Propane Patio Heaters 2026 · Best Deck Boxes for Your Patio 2026 · Best Adirondack Chairs 2026 · Best Outdoor String Lights 2026 · Best Smokeless Fire Pits 2026 · Best Gazebos 2026 · Best Outdoor Rocking Chairs 2026 · Best Outdoor Benches 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What size propane tank do these fire pits use?
Fire Sense lists a hinged door for a 20 pound tank and Solo Stove lists a hidden compartment for a standard 20 pound tank. The Hiland listing on Amazon says it uses a 20 pound tank.
Which of these has the most heat?
Solo Stove lists up to 72,000 BTU, Fire Sense lists 55,000 BTU and Hiland lists 41,000 BTU.
Which one can double as a table?
Fire Sense lists a fire bowl lid that converts the Florence to a patio table. Hiland’s Amazon listing mentions a stainless steel lid, and Solo Stove’s page does not list a lid.
How long does a tank last?
Solo Stove lists about 5.5 hours on a full 20 pound tank on its highest setting. Fire Sense and Hiland do not state a runtime on the pages we checked.
What warranties do these fire pits have?
Fire Sense lists 1 year, Solo Stove lists 3 years limited, and Hiland’s site does not state a term, so the Amazon listing’s 1 year limited warranty is shown. Each card links the manufacturer’s page where we found one.
