Researched comparisonLast updated October 2026 · How we review
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products from established brands.
Quick Answer
We would start with the Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet at $31.50 if you want an uncoated aluminum pan with a 500°F oven limit and a lifetime warranty on Nordic Ware’s page. The USA Pan 1050HS at $24.95 has a nonstick coating, a 450°F limit and a limited lifetime warranty. The Wilton Silver Non-Stick Large Baking Sheet at $19.27 is the lowest price and is listed as dishwasher safe.
- Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet: best for bakers who want an uncoated aluminum pan with a 500°F oven limit and a lifetime warranty.
- USA Pan Half Sheet 1050HS: best for bakers who want an aluminized steel pan with a nonstick coating, a 450°F oven limit and a limited lifetime warranty.
- Wilton Silver Non-Stick Large Baking Sheet: best for bakers who want a dishwasher-safe non-stick steel pan made without PFAS.
Prices as of October 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT.
A rimmed baking sheet is the pan you reach for to roast vegetables, bake cookies and cook a sheet-pan dinner. We put three half-sheet-size pans from Nordic Ware, USA Pan and Wilton side by side on size, material and coating, oven limit, dishwasher use, weight and warranty.
How We Chose
We compared one half-sheet pan each from Nordic Ware, USA Pan and Wilton, all about 17 x 12 inches. They are not identical: the Nordic Ware is uncoated aluminum, while the USA Pan and the Wilton are steel pans with a nonstick coating, and the Wilton is a little smaller at 17 x 11 in. Each manufacturer’s page names its own pan size, so the figures are not measured the same way. We take specs from each manufacturer’s page where it gave one, and each cell names its source. Warranty terms come from the manufacturer’s own website where it names the model or product line, then from the Amazon listing, and we say so where neither gave a length. Prices are Amazon prices checked in October 2026 and can change.
The Lineup
Specs come from each manufacturer’s own pages. † Nordic Ware’s page is for the closest model, SKU 43100. Prices as of October 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. Amazon may show a different seller than the brand or Amazon.com. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided “as is” and is subject to change or removal at any time.
Nordic Ware Naturals Aluminum Baker’s Half Sheet
$31.50 as of Oct 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT on Amazon · highest oven limit, lifetime warranty
Best for: bakers who want an uncoated aluminum pan with a 500°F oven limit and a lifetime warranty.
We like the Naturals half sheet for its oven limit and warranty. Nordic Ware’s page for the Naturals Baker’s Half Sheet (SKU 43100) lists 17.9 x 12.9 x 1 in outside and 17.1 x 12.1 in usable, pure uncoated aluminum, 1.6 lb, oven safe to 500°F, and a lifetime warranty. It is made in America of domestic and imported materials, and the page advises hand washing. Amazon’s listing shows model 43105AMZM, so we treat the 43100 page as the closest model.
Warranty: Lifetime
Check Price on Amazon →USA Pan Bakeware Nonstick Half Sheet Pan (1050HS)
$24.95 as of Oct 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT on Amazon · nonstick coating, limited lifetime warranty
Best for: bakers who want an aluminized steel pan with a nonstick coating, a 450°F oven limit and a limited lifetime warranty.
We like the USA Pan for a nonstick finish with a warranty to match. USA Pan’s page for the half sheet (item 1050HS-1) lists 17.75 x 12.75 x 1 in outside and a 17.25 x 12.25 in baking surface, aluminized steel with an Americoat nonstick silicone coating, oven safe to 450°F, and a limited lifetime warranty. It is made in the USA from globally sourced materials, and the page says not to place it in the dishwasher. USA Pan does not publish a weight.
Warranty: Limited lifetime
Check Price on Amazon →Wilton Silver Non-Stick Large Baking Sheet (17 x 11 in)
$19.27 as of Oct 19, 2026, 9:49 pm CT on Amazon · lowest price, dishwasher safe
Best for: bakers who want a dishwasher-safe non-stick steel pan made without PFAS.
We like the Wilton as the lowest price option. Wilton’s page for SKU 191011718 lists a 17 x 11 in pan, steel construction with a non-stick coating, a statement that it is made without PFAS, and dishwasher-safe care with a suggestion to wash in warm soapy water for best results. The page says the product is designed in the USA. It does not list an oven limit, a weight or a warranty length, and Amazon’s title gives 17 x 11.5 in, so we use Wilton’s figure.
Warranty: Wilton’s Limited Warranty
Check Price on Amazon →Our Take
We would start with the Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet at $31.50 for most kitchens: uncoated aluminum, a 500°F oven limit and a lifetime warranty. We would pick the USA Pan at $24.95 if you want a nonstick coating and a limited lifetime warranty. We would pick the Wilton at $19.27 if price and dishwasher use matter most, keeping in mind that its page gives no oven limit and its warranty page does not tie a term to this model. Nonstick coatings and dishwashers can wear pans over time, so follow each page’s care notes.
More Kitchen Guides: All Kitchen Guides · Best Air Fryers 2026 · Best Dutch Ovens 2026 · Best Stand Mixers 2026 · Best Kitchen Gifts for the Cook Who Already Has Everything · Best Non-Toxic Cookware for Gas Stoves · Best Roasting Pans 2026 · Best Espresso Machines 2026 · Best Rice Cookers 2026 · Best Hand Mixers 2026 · Best Waffle Makers 2026 · Best Knife Sets 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best baking sheet overall?
We would start with the Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet for most people: it lists uncoated aluminum, a 500°F oven limit and a lifetime warranty on Nordic Ware’s page, at $31.50. We like the USA Pan 1050HS if you want a nonstick coating, and the Wilton as the lowest price option.
Can I put these baking sheets in the dishwasher?
Nordic Ware advises against dishwasher use, and USA Pan says not to place its pan in the dishwasher. Wilton’s page lists its pan as dishwasher safe but suggests warm soapy water for best results.
How hot can these baking sheets go?
Nordic Ware lists 500°F and USA Pan lists 450°F. Wilton’s page does not list an oven limit, so check the packaging before using it at high heat.
What warranty do these baking sheets have?
We take these from the manufacturers: Nordic Ware’s page lists a lifetime warranty, and USA Pan’s page lists a limited lifetime warranty. Wilton’s warranty page lists limited warranties but does not say which term covers this model, so we show no length for it. Terms can differ by seller and region, so we suggest you confirm before you buy.
