Researched comparisonLast updated November 2026 · How we review
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products from established brands.
Quick Answer
We would start with the Weber Spirit E-425 ($679) as the safe, long warranty choice, with 10 years on the cookbox, lid and burner tubes per Weber’s product page. These four propane grills span $347 to $749, and the price gap shows up in the specs. The Broil King Crown S 440 ($749) has the longest cookbox warranty here, a lifetime warranty, plus 630 square inches in total and a 10,000 BTU side burner. The Char-Broil ($347) is the budget option, and the Nexgrill ($449.00) adds a fifth burner and lists the most cooking area here, 771.69 square inches in total.
- Weber Spirit E-425: best for buyers who want four burners and a 10 year warranty on the cookbox, lid and burner tubes, without a side burner.
- Broil King Crown S 440: best for buyers who want four burners plus a 10,000 BTU side burner, 630 sq in and a lifetime cookbox warranty.
- Char-Broil Performance 4-Burner (cabinet, black): best for buyers who want four burners plus a side burner in a cabinet design, with a 5 year warranty on the stainless burners.
- Nexgrill 5-Burner with Searing Side Burner: best for buyers who want five burners, a 15,000 BTU searing side burner and the most listed cooking area here, and can accept a 1 year warranty on most parts.
Prices as of November 7, 2026, 1:56 pm CT.
A gas grill is the most common backyard grill in America, and the right one depends mostly on how much cooking space you need and how long you want it to last. We cover one four burner propane gas grill each from Weber, Broil King, and Char-Broil, plus a five burner propane model from Nexgrill, all available on Amazon, and all but the Weber have a side burner.
How We Chose
We picked four established grill brands that sell a four or five burner propane gas grill on Amazon, and compared price, burner count, cooking area, warranty, and construction. The Nexgrill has five burners instead of four, so it is not an exact match, and we say so in the table. Burner count and cooking area come from each manufacturer’s own page or manual where it gave a value, and where it did not the cell says Not published by that brand. We take warranty terms from the manufacturer’s page or manual for the model, and each cell says which. We only list numbers that a manufacturer page or manual gives. Prices are Amazon prices checked in November 2026 and can change, and Amazon lists several colors and configurations of some of these grills, so check that the model on the page matches what you want.
The Lineup
Specs come from each manufacturer’s own pages. Prices as of November 7, 2026, 1:56 pm CT. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. Amazon may show a different seller than the brand or Amazon.com. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided “as is” and is subject to change or removal at any time.
Weber Spirit E-425
$679.00 as of Nov 7, 2026, 1:56 pm CT on Amazon · 10 year cookbox and burner warranty
Best for: buyers who want four burners and a 10 year warranty on the cookbox, lid and burner tubes, without a side burner.
We like the Weber as the safe pick, for its long cookbox, lid and burner tube warranty. The Spirit E-425 is Weber’s mainstream four burner propane grill. Weber’s product page describes two Boost Burners that add power to the Sear Zone, Snap-Jet ignition, stainless steel Flavorizer bars that catch and vaporize drippings, and porcelain-enameled cast iron cooking grates. Weber’s product page lists 10 years on the cookbox, lid and burner tubes, 5 years on the grates and Flavorizer bars, and 2 years on all other parts, and it works with Weber’s add on grillware such as pizza oven and wok kits, sold separately. Weber’s product page lists 533 square inches in total, 428 primary plus a 105 square inch warming rack, and no side burner. It is available on Amazon.
Warranty: 10 years on cookbox, lid and burner tubes, 5 years on grates and Flavorizer bars, 2 years on other parts
Check Price on Amazon →Broil King Crown S 440
$749.00 as of Nov 7, 2026, 1:56 pm CT on Amazon · 630 sq in, 40,000 BTU
Best for: buyers who want four burners plus a 10,000 BTU side burner, 630 sq in and a lifetime cookbox warranty.
We would pick the Broil King if you want a lifetime cookbox warranty and are willing to pay for it. Broil King is a Canadian grill manufacturer. Broil King’s product page for the Crown S 440 (SKU 865364) lists 630 square inches of total cooking space, made up of a 460 square inch primary cooking space and a warming rack, four stainless dual tube burners delivering 40,000 BTUs, and a 10,000 BTU side burner. It has three position cast iron cooking grids and a stainless steel Flav-R-Wave system under the grids that vaporizes drippings. It is the most expensive grill here and Broil King’s product page lists a lifetime warranty on the cookbox, 10 years on the burners, 5 years on stainless steel components, and 2 years on remaining parts and paint. It is available on Amazon.
Warranty: Lifetime on cookbox, 25 years on lid components, 10 years on burners, 5 years on stainless steel components, 3 years on heat medium, 2 years on cast iron, side burner and remaining parts and paint
Check Price on Amazon →Char-Broil Performance Series 4-Burner (Cabinet, Black)
$347.00 as of Nov 7, 2026, 1:56 pm CT on Amazon · cabinet design with side burner
Best for: buyers who want four burners plus a side burner in a cabinet design, with a 5 year warranty on the stainless burners.
We like the Char-Broil as our budget pick from a known brand, with a side burner and a cabinet design. This four burner cabinet model, Char-Broil model 463253925, has a side burner. Char-Broil does not publish the cooking area for this exact model, and its manual lists a 5 year warranty on the stainless burners, 2 years on the firebox and lid, and 1 year on all other parts for the original purchaser. It is the best value of the name brand grills here at about half the price of the Weber. It is available on Amazon.
Warranty: 5 years on stainless burners, 2 years on firebox and lid, 1 year on all other parts, original purchaser only
Check Price on Amazon →Nexgrill 5-Burner Gas Grill with Searing Side Burner
$449.00 as of Nov 7, 2026, 1:56 pm CT on Amazon · five burners, 771 sq in
Best for: buyers who want five burners, a 15,000 BTU searing side burner and the most listed cooking area here, and can accept a 1 year warranty on most parts.
We would pick the Nexgrill if you want the most cooking space and five burners for well under the Weber’s price, and can live with a shorter warranty. Nexgrill is a lower priced gas grill brand. Nexgrill’s page for model 720-1046A lists five stainless steel main burners, a 15,000 BTU ceramic searing side burner, porcelain cast iron cooking grids, a stainless steel lid and a two door cabinet. It lists 547.69 square inches of primary cooking area and 771.69 in total, the most listed here. It costs about $100 more than the Char-Broil and well below the Weber and the Broil King. The Nexgrill manual lists 8 years on the tube burners and 1 year on the cooking grids, flame tamers, stainless steel parts and all other parts. It is available on Amazon.
Warranty: 8 years on tube burners, 1 year on all other parts
Check Price on Amazon →Our Take
If you want a grill that will still be going in ten years and is backed by a long warranty, we would pick the Weber Spirit E-425 as the safe choice. If you want the longest cookbox warranty and are willing to pay for it, we would look at the Broil King Crown S 440, which lists a lifetime warranty on the cookbox. If you are on a budget, we like the Char-Broil as a known brand at $347, and the Nexgrill is the way to get five burners and the most listed cooking area for less than the Weber.
More Grilling Guides: All Grilling Guides · Best 36 Inch Griddles 2026 · Best Charcoal Kettle Grills 2026 · Best Instant-Read Meat Thermometers 2026 · Best Grill Tongs 2026 · Best Pellet Grills 2026 · Best Portable Gas Grills 2026 · Best Charcoal Chimney Starters 2026 · Best Premium Pellet Grills 2026 · Best Premium Kamado Grills 2026 · Best Premium Gas Grills 2026 · Best Electric Smokers 2026 · Best Turkey Fryers 2026 · Best Wireless Meat Thermometers 2026 · Best Outdoor Pizza Ovens 2026 · Best Offset Smokers 2026 · Best Electric Grills 2026 · Best Grill Covers 2026 · Best Portable Charcoal Grills 2026 · Best Lump Charcoal 2026
Related in other categories: Best Smokeless Fire Pits 2026 · Best Outdoor String Lights 2026 · Best Adirondack Chairs 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
How many burners do I need on a propane gas grill?
We think four burners is a common size for a family of four to six, and it gives you room for direct and indirect heat zones. Two or three burners work for small patios, and five or more matter mainly if you cook for large groups. The Nexgrill here has five burners and lists 771.69 square inches in total, while the four burner Broil King lists 630 and the four burner Weber 533, so we would check the cooking area as well as the burner count.
Are BTUs the best way to compare gas grills?
Not by themselves, in our view. BTUs describe maximum heat output, but cooking area, burner design, and how well the grill holds heat matter as much. We compare BTU per square inch of cooking area if the manufacturer’s page gives both numbers.
What is the difference between a cabinet and a cart gas grill?
A cabinet grill has an enclosed base for storing your propane tank and gear, while a cart style has an open base. We like cabinets because they look cleaner and protect the tank from weather. Check the manufacturer’s product page to make sure you are getting the base style you want.
How long does a gas grill last?
It depends on the materials and how well you maintain it. Cast aluminum and stainless steel bodies and porcelain coated grates resist rust longer, and a longer warranty is one signal of the manufacturer’s confidence. We would cover the grill and clean the grates and burners regularly, which helps any grill last longer.



